COVID-19 latent age-specific mortality in US states: a county-level spatio-temporal analysis with counterfactuals

Abstract

During the COVID-19 pandemic, which spanned much of 2020-2023 and beyond, daily case and death counts were recorded globally. In this study, we examined available mortality counts and associated case counts, with a focus on the estimation missing information related to age distributions. In this paper, we explored a model-based paradigm for generating age distributions of mortality counts in a spatio-temporal context. We pursued this aim by employing Bayesian spatio-temporal lagged dependence models for weekly mortality at the county level. We compared three US states at the county level: South Carolina (SC), Ohio, and New Jersey (NJ). Models were developed for mortality counts using Bayesian spatio-temporal constructs, incorporating both dependence on current and cumulative case counts and lagged dependence on previous deaths. Age dependence was predicted based on total deaths in proportion to population estimates. This latent age field was generated as counterfactuals and then compared to observed deaths within age groups. The optimal retrospective space-time models for weekly mortality counts were those with lagged dependence and a function of caseload. Added random effects were found to vary across states: Ohio favored a spatially correlated model, while SC and NJ favored a simpler formulation. The generation of age-specific latent fields was performed for SC only and compared to a 15-month, 13-county data set of observed >65 age population. It is possible to model spatio-temporal variations in mortality at the county level with lagged dependencies, spatial effects, and case dependencies. In addition, it is also possible to generate latent age-specific fields based on estimates of death risk (using population proportions or more sophisticated modeling approaches). More detailed data will be needed to make more calibrated comparisons for future epidemic monitoring. The proposed discrepancy tool could serve as a useful resource for public health planners in tailoring interventions during epidemic situations.

Keywords: Bayesian; COVID-19; age-specific; counterfactuals; mortality; spatio-temporal.