Seeing is Believing - A Qualitative Study Exploring What Motivates Medical Students to Pursue a Career In General Surgery

J Surg Educ. 2024 Aug;81(8):1050-1056. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2024.05.016. Epub 2024 Jun 20.

Abstract

Objective: The personal statement (PS) is a rich text in which medical students introduce themselves to the programs to which they are applying. There is no prompt or agreed upon structure for the personal statement. Therefore it represents a window in to medical students' beliefs and perceptions. The goal of this study was to identify what events or experiences motivate medial students to pursue a career in general surgery. Previous work in this area has been largely survey and interview-based. This study is unique in that it looks at what medical students say when not prompted.

Design: This is a single-institution, retrospective, qualitative review of applicants' PSs. The PSs were coded based on an a priori coding scheme. The coding scheme was based on published literature of why medical students might apply for a general surgery training position.

Setting: Academic, safety-net hospital.

Participants: The study evaluated a subset of the PSs of applications submitted through the Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS) for a categorical general surgery position in our program during the 2022 match. Specifically, 308 of all received applications were included in this study. This is the subgroup of applications that was pulled out for a close review based on holistic screening of received applications.

Results: The single most frequently mentioned motivating factor for applying to general surgery training was the experience a student had on the surgery clerkship. The early years of medical school and sub-internships were less frequently identified as motivating experiences. After the overall clerkship experience, the next most frequent motivating factors were that their personality fit well with the culture of surgery and that they realized the important role surgeons played in patient care. 59 applicants wrote about a pre-existing interest in surgery prior to entering medical school. Most frequently this interest developed after witnessing family or friends or applicant themselves have surgery or shadowing a surgeon.

Conclusions: In this study, students most frequently noted the clerkship experience as having sparked their interest in a career in surgery. Having had exposure to surgeons, through personal experience or shadowing, often led to students to develop an interest in pursuing a career in surgery prior to entering medical school. The findings suggest that to increase the attractiveness of surgery to potential applicants, positive exposure to surgeons and surgery as a field of practice are critical.

Keywords: career choice; medical student; personal statement; residency selection.

MeSH terms

  • Adult
  • Career Choice*
  • Female
  • General Surgery* / education
  • Humans
  • Male
  • Motivation*
  • Qualitative Research*
  • Retrospective Studies
  • Students, Medical* / psychology
  • Students, Medical* / statistics & numerical data