The biomarker 5-chlorocytosine (5ClC) appears in the DNA of inflamed tissues. Replication of a site-specific 5ClC in a viral DNA genome results in C → T mutations, which is consistent with 5ClC acting as a thymine mimic in vivo. Direct damage of nucleic acids by immune-cell-derived hypochlorous acid is one mechanism by which 5ClC could appear in the genome. A second, nonmutually exclusive mechanism involves damage of cytosine nucleosides or nucleotides in the DNA precursor pool, with subsequent utilization of the 5ClC deoxynucleotide triphosphate as a precursor for DNA synthesis. The present work characterized the mutagenic properties of 5ClC in the nucleotide pool by exposing cells to the nucleoside 5-chloro-2'-deoxycytidine (5CldC). In both Escherichia coli and mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs), 5CldC in the growth media was potently mutagenic, indicating that 5CldC enters cells and likely is erroneously incorporated into the genome from the nucleotide pool. High-resolution sequencing of DNA from MEFs derived from the gptΔ C57BL/6J mouse allowed qualitative and quantitative characterization of 5CldC-induced mutations; CG → TA transitions in 5'-GC(Y)-3' contexts (Y = a pyrimidine) were dominant, while TA → CG transitions appeared at a much lower frequency. The high-resolution mutational spectrum of 5CldC revealed a notable similarity to the Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer mutational signatures SBS84 and SBS42, which appear in human lymphoid tumors and in occupationally induced cholangiocarcinomas, respectively. SBS84 is associated with the expression of activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), a cytosine deaminase associated with inflammation, as well as immunoglobulin gene diversification during antibody maturation. The similarity between the spectra of AID activation and 5CldC could be coincidental; however, the administration of 5CldC did induce some AID expression in MEFs, which have no inherent expression of its gene. In summary, this work shows that 5CldC induces a distinct pattern of mutations in cells. Moreover, that pattern resembles human mutational signatures induced by inflammatory processes, such as those triggered in certain malignancies.