Alginate-based hydrogels are a promising class of biomaterials due to their usability, biocompatibility, and high water-binding capacity which is the reason for their broad use in biofabrication. One challenge of these biomaterials is, however, the lack of cell adhesion motifs. This drawback can be overcome by oxidizing alginate to alginate dialdehyde (ADA) and by subsequent cross-linking with gelatin (GEL) to fabricate ADA-GEL hydrogels, which offer improved cell-material interactions. The present work investigates four pharmaceutical grade alginates of different algae sources and their respective oxidized forms regarding their molecular weight and M/G ratio using 1H NMR spectroscopy and gel permeation chromatography. In addition, three different methods for determining the degree of oxidation (% DO) of ADA, including iodometric, spectroscopic, and titration methods, are applied and compared. Furthermore, the aforementioned properties are correlated with the resulting viscosity, degradation behavior, and cell-material interactions to predict the material behavior in vitro and thus choose a suitable alginate for an intended application in biofabrication. In the framework of the present work, easy and practicable detection methods for the investigations of alginate-based bioinks were summarized and shown. In this regard, the success of oxidation of alginate was confirmed by the three aforementioned methods and was further proven by solid-state 13C NMR, for the first time in the literature, that only guluronic acid (G) was attacked during the oxidation, leading to the formation of hemiacetals. Furthermore, it was shown that ADA-GEL hydrogels of alginates with longer G-blocks are more suitable for long-term experiments due to their stability over an incubation period of 21 days, while ADA-GEL hydrogels of alginates with longer mannuronic acid (M)-blocks are more suitable for short-term applications such as sacrificial inks due to their extensive swelling and subsequent loss of shape. Finally, it was proven that the M/G ratio did not show any influence on the biocompatibility or printability of the investigated alginate-based hydrogels. The physicochemical findings provide an alginate library for tailored application in biofabrication.