Why is calcite a strong phosphorus sink in freshwater? Investigating the adsorption mechanism using batch experiments and surface complexation modeling

Abstract

One of the primary drivers of Phosphorus (P) limitation in aquatic systems is P adsorption to sediments. Sediments adsorb more P in freshwater compared to other natural solutions, but the mechanism driving this difference is poorly understood. To provide insights into the mechanism, we conducted batch experiments of P adsorption to calcite in freshwater and seawater, and used computer software to develop complexation models. Our simulations revealed three main reasons that, combining together, may explain the greater P adsorption to calcite in freshwater vs. seawater. First, aqueous speciation of P makes a difference. The ion pair CaPO₄^- is much more abundant in freshwater; although seawater has more Ca²⁺ ions, MgHPO₄⁰ and NaHPO₄⁰ are more thermodynamically favored. Second, the adsorbing species of P make a difference. The ion pair CaPO₄^- (the preferred adsorbate in freshwater) is able to access adsorption sites that are not available to HPO₄^2- (the preferred adsorbate in seawater), thereby raising the maximum concentration of P that can adsorb to the calcite surface in freshwater. Third, water chemistry affects the competition among ions for surface sites. Other ions (including P) compete more effectively against CO₃^2- when immersed in freshwater vs. seawater, even when the concentration of HCO₃^-/CO₃^2- is higher in freshwater vs. seawater. In addition, we found that under oligotrophic conditions, P adsorption is driven by the higher energy adsorption sites, and by the lower energy sites in eutrophic conditions. This study is the first to model P adsorption mechanisms to calcite in freshwater and seawater.

Keywords: Abiotic factors; Calcium carbonate; Nutrient; Phosphates; Sediment dynamics.