Synthetic, sequence-random polymers that feature a wide range of backbone and side chain structures have been reported to function as mimics of natural host-defense peptides, inhibiting bacterial growth while exerting little or no toxicity toward eukaryotic cells. The common themes among these materials are net positive charge, which is thought to confer preferential action toward prokaryotic vs eukaryotic cells, and the presence of hydrophobic components, which are thought to mediate membrane disruption. This study is based on a set of new binary cationic-hydrophobic nylon-3 copolymers that was designed to ask whether factors beyond net charge and net hydrophobicity influence the biological activity profile. In previous work, we found that nonpolar subunits preorganized by a ring led to copolymers with a diminished tendency to disrupt human cell membranes (as measured via lysis of red blood cells) relative to copolymers containing more flexible nonpolar subunits. An alternative mode of conformational restriction, involving geminal substitution, also minimized hemolysis. Here, we asked whether combining a cyclic constraint and geminal substitution would be synergistic; the combination was achieved by introducing backbone methyl groups to previously described cyclopentyl and cyclohexyl subunits. The new cyclic subunits containing two quaternary backbone carbons (i.e, two sites of geminal substitution) were comparable or slightly superior in terms of antibacterial potency but markedly superior in terms of low hemolytic activity, relative to cyclic subunits lacking the quaternary carbons. However, new cyclic units containing only one quaternary carbon were very hemolytic, which was unanticipated. Variations in net hydrophobicity cannot explain the trend in hemolysis, in contrast to the standard perspective in this field. The impact of each new polymer on live E. coli cells was evaluated via fluorescence microscopy. All new polymers moved rapidly across the outer membrane without large-scale disruption of barrier function. Increasing the number of quaternary carbons in the nonpolar subunit correlated with an increased propensity to permeabilize the cytoplasmic membrane of E. coli cells. Collectively, these findings show that relationships between nonpolar subunit identity and biological activity are influenced by factors in addition to hydrophobicity and charge. We propose that the variation of subunit conformational properties may be one such factor.