Creating gender: A thematic analysis of genderqueer narratives

Nova J Bradford; G Nicole Rider; Jory M Catalpa; Quinlyn J Morrow; Dianne R Berg; Katherine G Spencer; Jenifer K McGuire

doi:10.1080/15532739.2018.1474516

Creating gender: A thematic analysis of genderqueer narratives

Int J Transgend. 2018 May 25;20(2-3):155-168. doi: 10.1080/15532739.2018.1474516. eCollection 2019.

Authors

Nova J Bradford¹, G Nicole Rider¹, Jory M Catalpa^{1

2}, Quinlyn J Morrow², Dianne R Berg¹, Katherine G Spencer¹, Jenifer K McGuire²

Affiliations

¹ National Center for Gender Spectrum Health, Program in Human Sexuality, Department of Family Medicine and Community Health, University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, USA.
² Department of Family Social Science, University of Minnesota, St Paul, USA.

Abstract

Background and Aims: Increasingly, research is emerging on the subjective experience of genderqueer people. This study explored how genderqueer identities are understood and managed in both personal and social domains. Method: Interview data from 25 genderqueer-identified American adolescents and emerging adults, aged 15 to 26 (M = 21.28, SD = 3.20), were pulled from a larger study of 90 transgender and genderqueer participants. The 90-minute semi-structured interviews included questions about gender identity, the developmental pathway of participants, and relationships with others regarding gender. Results: Participants described "genderqueer" as a sufficiently broad category to capture their diverse experiences, and descriptions of genderqueer identities were heterogeneous, directly contradicting binary understandings of gender identity. A thematic analysis of interview transcripts resulted in three themes: intrapsychic experience, descriptions of master narratives about gender identity, and the co-construction of identities. Discussion: Participants described navigating a series of master and alternative narratives, such that all transgender people transgress a cisnormative master narrative, but genderqueer people further transgress normative understandings of a medicalized, binary transgender identity. The experience of co-creating identities was the process by which participants actively navigated constraints of the master narrative experience. Participants described the integral role of language in crafting new narratives to legitimize genderqueer experiences, as well as the subsequent intragroup conflict resulting from conflicting relationships to narratives in the transgender community. This study highlights genderqueer identities as a source of strength and positivity, and the importance of expanding beyond the hegemonic gender binary within research and clinical practice.

Keywords: alternative narratives; genderqueer; identity development; master narratives; narrative identity; transgender.