Gastric cancer (GC) remains a leading cause of cancer mortality worldwide. Genetic factors are implicated, including DNA mismatch repair (MMR) deficiency manifested as tumor microsatellite instability (MSI). However, a standardized panel of markers and a definition of low-versus-high level MSI in GC are lacking. We examined a population-based cohort of early onset (<or=50 yrs) gastric cancer. We identified 211 cases of early onset gastric cancer in Central-East Ontario from 1989 to 1993, with archival material available for 139 cases. Testing included a six-mononucleotide marker panel and a three-MMR immunohistochemical panel. Overall, 30% (41 of 139) of GC were MSI+, with allelic shifts at one to eight markers. An unexpected discordance between the BAT-25, BAT-26, and BAT-40 markers was observed in the MSI+ cases. Six cases showing multiple loci instability (>or=3 markers MSI+/MSI-high) demonstrated MMR protein deficiency. Three novel hMLH1 mutations (two germline frameshift and one somatic nonsense) were also found. The only significant clinicopathological associations were increased tumor size in MSI+ cases (P=0.04) and Lauren histotype (P=0.006) and tumor grade (P=0.007) in MSI-high cases. Tumor size, location, depth, nodal status, and Ming subtype were significant prognostic variables. Therefore, we propose a new definition of high-level MSI based on unifying characteristics of instability of more than or equal to three of six mononucleotide markers and loss of MMR protein expression.