The mechanisms by which alpha-adrenergic stimulation of the heart in vivo can cause contractile dysfunction are not well understood. We hypothesized that alpha-adrenergic-mediated contractile dysfunction is mediated through protein kinase C phosphorylation of troponin I, which in in vitro experiments has been shown to reduce actomyosin Mg-ATPase activity. We studied pressure-volume loops in transgenic mice expressing mutant troponin I lacking protein kinase C phosphorylation sites and hypothesized altered responses to phenylephrine. As anesthesia agents can produce markedly different effects on contractility, we studied two agents: avertin and alpha-chloralose-urethane. With alpha-chloralose-urethane, at baseline, there were no contractile abnormalities in the troponin I mutants. Phenylephrine produced a 50% reduction in end-systolic elastance in wild-type controls, although a 9% increase in troponin I mutants (P <0.05). Avertin was associated with reduced contractility compared with alpha-chloralose-urethane. Avertin anesthesia, at baseline, produced a reduction in end-systolic elastance by 31% in the troponin I mutants compared with wild-type (P <0.05), and this resulted in further marked systolic and diastolic dysfunction with phenylephrine in the troponin I mutants. Dobutamine produced no significant difference in the contractile phenotype of the transgenic mice with either anesthetic regimen. In conclusion, these data (alpha-chloralose-urethane) demonstrate that alpha-adrenergic-mediated force reduction is mediated through troponin I protein kinase C phosphorylation. beta-Adrenergic responses are not mediated through this pathway. Altering the myofilament force-calcium relationship may result in in vivo increased sensitivity to negative inotropy. Thus choice of a negative inotropic anesthetic agent (avertin) with phenylephrine can lead to profound contractile dysfunction.