Background: Since January, 1984, 59 children with histologically confirmed Ewing sarcoma of the pelvic bone have been treated with three successive chemotherapy protocols recommended by the French Society of Pediatric Oncology. The purpose of the current study was to evaluate the role of surgery and/or radiotherapy in local progression-free, disease-free, and overall survivals (LPFS, DFS, and OS, respectively).
Procedure: We retrospectively examined 59 children treated for nonmetastatic, pelvic Ewing sarcoma over the last 12 years. All were first treated with chemotherapy according to the current French protocol. Six patients developed progressive disease before local treatment and were excluded for local control and survival analysis. Local treatment was surgery alone in 17 cases, radiation therapy in 27 cases, and surgery plus radiation therapy in 9 cases.
Results: With a median of follow-up of 6.5 years, no significant differences in local control or survival were observed with the three chemotherapeutic protocols. Of the 53 patients evaluable for local control, 6 relapsed locally only, 8 had local and distant relapses, and 9 had distant metastases only. The 5-year OS rate was worst for patients with radiotherapy alone compared to those with surgery or combined modality treatment (44 % vs. 72 %, P = 0.043). The 5-year LPFS and DFS rates were worst in the radiotherapy-alone group but not significantly (63% vs. 79%, P = 0. 22 and 42% vs 71%, P =0.07, respectively). The importance of surgery to OS and DFS was confirmed by multivariate analysis (P = 0.026 and P = 0.048, respectively). One surviving patient was diagnosed with in-field fibrosarcoma, which was presumably radiation induced.
Conclusions: Despite intensive, multiagent chemotherapy, survival from pelvic Ewing sarcoma has not improved over the past decade; however, the survival rate does not seem to be worse than that from Ewing sarcoma at other locations, insofar as at least 50% of the patients were cured. Surgery or a combination of surgery and radiation therapy are the best local treatment; exclusive radiation therapy should be reserved for patients with inoperable lesions or partially or nonchemosensitive tumors or when surgery would be an amputation.
Copyright 1999 Wiley-Liss, Inc.